How traffic noise hurts children’s brains

Emmanuel Lafont/BBC An illustration of a boy with his fingers in his ears to block out traffic noise (Credit: Emmanuel Lafont/BBC)Emmanuel Lafont/BBC

Children are particularly vulnerable to noise pollution from traffic (Credit: Emmanuel Lafont/BBC)

As awareness grows of the toll noise has on children’s health and learning, some cities show the way to quieter roads and classrooms.

In a New York classroom, noise levels were so high that the teacher had to scream to be heard. The classroom was located near a subway train on raised tracks which passed by Public School 98 in Manhattan about 15 times a day, causing constant interruptions in the learning process. 

For many years, people had complained about the noise levels at Public School 98, and in 1975, Arline Bronzaft, associate professor of psychology at Herbert H. Lehman College of the City University of New York, published a study examining the impact of noise on children’s reading ability. She found that students who sat on the noisy side of the school building adjacent to the tracks performed poorly on reading tests compared to those on the quiet side of the building. The average reading scores of the classes on the noisy side lagged three to four months behind those of students on the quieter side

Emmanuel Lafont/BBC Excessive noise has a detrimental impact on children's health and development (Credit: Emmanuel Lafont/BBC)Emmanuel Lafont/BBC

Excessive noise has a detrimental impact on children’s health and development (Credit: Emmanuel Lafont/BBC)

Noise pollution is a growing global problem. As populations increase, so do the noise levels that form the urban soundscape. The UN has warned that urban noise pollution is becoming a “global public health menace”, which already leads to 12,000 premature deaths each year in the European Union, and affects an estimated 100 million Americans

From Buenos Aires to Barcelona, cities have started introducing measures to tackle noise pollution, protect children’s health, and prioritise pedestrians by improving inner city green spaces, reducing speed limits and introducing sound meters. 

Deafening roads

In the US and European Union, road, rail and aircraft traffic are the dominant sources of noise pollution.

A 2022 study found that road traffic noise experienced by primary school children in Barcelona, Spain, slowed down their working memory and attention span, which is considered essential for many aspects of learning including problem-solving, reasoning, mathematics, and language comprehension.

Emmanuel Lafont/BBC Road traffic noise slows down children's working memory and attention span (Credit: Emmanuel Lafont/BBC)Emmanuel Lafont/BBC

Road traffic noise slows down children’s working memory and attention span (Credit: Emmanuel Lafont/BBC)

The study tested 2,700 children aged between seven and 10 years in 38 schools in Barcelona, Spain, four times a year. The researchers measured the external noise, at specific points within each classroom, repeating the process six months later to determine the average baseline level of noise pollution. Over the course of a year, the team performed online cognitive tests to evaluate the children’s short-term memory and attentiveness every three months.

Noise can negatively affect children’s brains during crucial stages of development

The Barcelona study, which built on previous research, found that noise levels generated by road, air and rail traffic can have a negative impact on children’s cognitive function during the crucial stages of brain development. Unwanted noise in the classroom can cause a child to experience several possible negative responses, such as learned helplessness – low motivation to learn due to the lack of control in their environment – and impaired attention, the study found. 

How loud is too loud?

• In primary schools, average noise levels are 44 decibels when pupils are silent, 56 decibels when pupils are engaged in quiet activities, 65 decibels for individual work, such as working at tables where some talking is allowed, and 70-77 decibels for group work. 

The Barcelona study was the first to investigate the impact of exposure to noise fluctuation. The researchers found that sudden fluctuations of noise, from traffic outside the classroom, such as car honks or engine revving, were more likely to distract children, and cause them to miss important information, even at a lower than average noise level.

Maria Foraster, lead author of the study, researcher in epidemiology and an expert on noise and health, says the researchers decided to focus on noise fluctuations as there are no international guidelines in place that measure this. 

“The guidelines don’t [mention] fluctuations and peaks. Every time there is a noise peak, it is a distraction which can affect children’s attention [span] and working memory,” says Foraster. 

Emmanuel Lafont/BBC Traffic noise can negatively impact children's cognitive function during the crucial stages of brain development (Credit: Emmanuel Lafont/BBC)Emmanuel Lafont/BBC

Traffic noise can negatively impact children’s cognitive function during the crucial stages of brain development (Credit: Emmanuel Lafont/BBC)

A 2019 study from Birkbeck University in London, which analysed the impact of noise in classrooms, found that children between 5-11 years of age are especially vulnerable to noise if they have lower selective attention – meaning, the ability to maintain focus and block out unwanted distraction – and inhibitory control, which is the ability to control urges and think before reacting.

When there is a lot of noise around children, they do worse academically – Natasha Kirkham

“If a child has poor working memory and if their selective attention or their inhibitory control is not great, then they are going to be much more distracted by the noise around them,” says Natasha Kirkham, co-author of the study and a professor in developmental psychology at Birkbeck University in London.

“When there is a lot of noise around children in primary and secondary school, we know they do worse [academically],” she says.  

Exposure to noise together with other factors that come from attending “a lower-resourced school in a lower-resourced area, can have a real knock-on effect to learning,” says Kirkham.

The association between noise and stress may have lifelong consequences, research suggests.

“If you constantly feel aroused by sound, this could increase the cortisol response related to stress, and over time can have detrimental effects on physical and emotional health from childhood into adulthood,” says Iroise Dumontheill, professor of cognitive neuroscience at Birkbeck University in London.

Noise exposure in childhood could affect memory and health in adulthood – Iroise Dumontheill

Continuous exposure to noise in the long term can interfere with the central nervous system and brain, increasing the likelihood of developing heart disease, stroke, dementia, and cognitive decline. 

“So, potentially, noise exposure in childhood could affect the memory systems and mental health in adulthood,” says Dumontheill. 

Car-free zones 

The best way to protect children from excessive noise is by reducing traffic around schools, says Foraster. Better urban design, such as separating schools from busy roads and adding parks and green spaces around school areas could also improve the learning environment for children, she says. 

Emmanuel Lafont/BBC Barcelona has introduced car-free neighbourhoods to protect children from noise pollution (Credit: Emmanuel Lafont/BBC)Emmanuel Lafont/BBC

Barcelona has introduced car-free neighbourhoods to protect children from noise pollution (Credit: Emmanuel Lafont/BBC)

Barcelona is trying to do this by placing schools into so-called “superilles”, or “superblocks”, which are small neighbourhoods closed to through traffic and packed with green spaces where people can exercise or get together. 

First introduced in 1993, this urban design concept aims to reduce air and noise pollution, by prioritising cyclists and pedestrians over cars and playgrounds and trees over parking spots. (Read more about Barcelona’s car-free smart city experiment.)

The superblocks have been shown to reduce noise and air pollution in residential neighbourhoods in Barcelona. The creation of the San Antoni superblock has lowered average daytime noise levels by 3.5 decibels, a 5.2% reduction, according to data gathered over one year by sensors and sonometers and compiled in a 2021 report.  It has also helped reduce air pollution

Reducing traffic around schools it seen as the best way to protect children from noise pollution

“Superblocks definitely help reduce air pollution and exposure to noise,” says Foraster. “They help reduce overall traffic by making the use of cars less attractive and promoting a more walkable city.” 

Quieter schools and neighbourhoods could potentially have another benefit: happier children. Kirkham points out that noise not only affects how children learn – it may also affect how they feel. 

A home-schooling study carried out by Kirkham during the Covid-19 pandemic, found that adolescents from noisier homes, who spent time in noisier classrooms, generally found noise more annoying. ”It’s not just that noise is distracting, there is an emotional component. Children get irritated,” she says.